Soy sauce substitute – best alternative!

The desire to replace soy sauce in the kitchen can have various reasons. Some fear the impact of soy on health – soy contains natural plant compounds called phytoestrogens, and while research on their effects is mixed and moderate consumption is considered safe for most people, some still prefer to avoid them, especially when the soy is derived from GMO crops. Others fear the excessive amount of salt in this product, looking for additives and spices with a similar taste, but without the harmful salt for hypertensive patients. The third group of people is looking for the intense umami taste typical for Asian dishes, however, they do not like the aftertaste of soy sauce. The reason can also be a soy allergy. There are many ways to replace soy sauce – what to replace soy sauce with, however, depends on the goal we set ourselves. Therefore, the proposed methods are sometimes opposite.
Soy sauce substitute – what are the alternatives?
In Chinese cuisine, no table salt is used: instead of salt, soy sauce, oyster sauce, or fish sauce are added to dishes. The most obvious substitute for soy sauce in hot Asian dishes we prepare is simply – salt. Instead of soy sauce, it can be used in almost any Chinese dish, without obvious taste losses. In most Chinese dishes, fish sauce or oyster sauce will also work – this is a very good solution for anyone who is allergic to soy or fears GMOs. The English cuisine’s Worcestershire sauce (if you don’t have it in your kitchen, check out our suggestions – Worcestershire sauce – what to replace with?) and Marmite spice also have a similar taste.
What to replace soy sauce with for sushi?
Greater difficulty arises when we use soy sauce not as an ingredient, but as a standalone addition to dishes. This is also a common way soy sauce is used – what to replace it as an addition to sushi, rice, or Asian noodles seems therefore a difficult problem to solve. Oyster sauce and fish sauce have too intense a taste, while the broth is too thin.
However, there is a soy sauce substitute that is easy to prepare at home, which will also work as an addition to sushi. For this purpose, prepare a very intense beef broth with the addition of dried mushrooms. This broth needs to be evaporated to remove at least half of the water – if it is still too thin, it can be thickened further with potato flour. Molasses or thick caramel will give it an intense dark color. You can add a bit of vinegar to taste.
What instead of soy sauce if we want to reduce the amount of salt in dishes?
Soy sauce contains large amounts of salt, which is unhealthy for people with hypertension. Often, however, we do not want to give up its taste. A good solution in this situation is miso paste. It is produced similarly to soy sauce, but this substitute contains much less salt.
It is worth choosing dark miso paste, which has a more intense taste. If we wonder what to use instead of soy sauce in a low-sodium diet, yeast extract is also a solution. It is completely devoid of salt, but its taste is similar.
Soy sauce substitute with umami taste
Soy sauce can also be replaced with any ingredient that has a clear umami taste. Such additives include especially mushroom broths. In many dishes, a substitute for soy sauce from European cuisine will also work – a spice like Maggi, and even ordinary broth cubes. The main source of umami taste in them is monosodium glutamate (MSG). This additive has an undeservedly bad reputation – major food safety authorities, including the FDA and EFSA, consider it safe for the general population in normal culinary amounts, though a small number of people report sensitivity to it. It can also be purchased in its pure form in many Asian food stores.
Soy Sauce Substitute – Best Alternative
Comparison of the most common substitutes for soy sauce, including gluten-free options.
| Substitute | Gluten-free | Flavor | Best used for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tamari | Yes | Very similar, slightly milder | Gluten-free dishes, sushi |
| Coconut aminos | Yes | Sweeter, milder | Paleo, vegan dishes |
| Fish sauce (not vegetarian) | Depends on product | Fishier, saltier | Thai, Vietnamese dishes |
| Salt + a bit of vegetable broth | Yes | Simpler, less umami | Emergency substitute with no other options |
Frequently asked questions about soy sauce substitutes
Can tamari replace soy sauce in sushi?
Yes, tamari has a very similar taste to soy sauce and is also gluten-free, which makes it a popular substitute.
What can replace soy sauce on a paleo diet?
Coconut aminos are a natural, sweeter substitute for soy sauce and are accepted on a paleo diet.
Does fish sauce work as a substitute for soy sauce in every dish?
Not quite – fish sauce has a stronger, fishier flavor, so it works especially well in Thai and Vietnamese cooking rather than as a universal substitute.

